Smoking in Cars Produces Harmful Pollutants at Levels Above WHO Indoor Air Quality Standards

(November 2, 2012)

[Second hand smoke in cars: assessing children’s potential exposure during typical journey conditions 2012; 578-83; doi 10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2011-050197] 

Statewide legislation banning smoking in cars when kids are present has been in force in Maine since 2008, but the American Lung Association of the Northeast is working hard to get similar laws passed in the remaining states in our region.  Research coming out of Aberdeen University, UK, shows just how crucial this work is to protect the health of child passengers. 

Smoking during car journeys pumps harmful particulate matter into the indoor air space at levels that far exceed World Health Organization guidance—even when the windows are open or air conditioning is switched on—finds the largest study of its kind, in Tobacco Control. 

Such levels of exposure are likely to affect the health of any child passengers, say the authors. 

Levels of fine particulate matter were measured every minute in the rear passenger area during typical car journeys made by smokers and non-smokers over a three day period. 

The measurements were made using an aerosol monitor that is frequently deployed to assess second hand smoke exposure, placed at child head height. 

Seventeen drivers, 14 of whom were smokers, made a total of 104 journeys, lasting from 5 to 70 minutes, with an average duration of 27 minutes. 

The journeys were made in various locations across the West of Scotland and around the East of England. 

Particulate matter levels were available for 83 journeys, of which 34 were smoke free. They averaged 7.4 μg/m3 during non-smoking journeys, but were around 10 times as high (85 μg/m3) during smoking journeys. 

Levels of particulate matter were strongly linked to the numbers of cigarettes smoked. Levels peaked at an average of 385 μg/m3, and on one occasion got as high as 880 μg/m3. 

Five of the smokers said they smoked 20 or more cigarettes a day; seven smoked between 10 and 19 a day; the rest smoked fewer than 10. 

Smokers tended to open car windows to provide some ventilation, but levels of particulate matter still exceeded the maximum safe limit recommended by the World Health Organization of 25 μg/m3 , at some point during all car journeys during which somebody smoked. 

The authors point out that exposure to second hand smoke is linked to several children’s health problems, including sudden infant death, middle ear disease, wheeze and asthma. 

“Children are likely to be at greater risk from [second hand smoke] exposure due to their faster breathing rates, less developed immune system and their inability to move away from the source in many home and car settings,” they say. 

They endorse the recent report from the Royal College of Physicians Tobacco Advisory Group, which called for a ban on smoking in cars, in a bid to reduce the overall prevalence of smoking and the harms associated with exposure to second hand smoke. 

Read the abstract in Tobacco Control and access the full article (with subscription).